by Chuck Baldwin
Much to the chagrin of the Southern Poverty Law Center, a federal judge has cleared the members of a Michigan militia who were accused by federal law enforcement agents of conspiracy to commit sedition. Since you didn’t hear much about this ruling from the national press corps, here is one online version of the report:
“Seven members of a Michigan militia have been cleared of plotting to overthrow the U.S. government as a judge dismissed the most serious charges against them.
“In a shock defeat for federal authorities, District Judge Victoria Roberts said the group’s expressed hatred of law enforcement did not amount to a conspiracy.
“The FBI secretly planted an informant and an agent inside the Hutaree militia in 2008 to collect hours of anti-government audio and video that became the cornerstone of the case.
“Senior officials had insisted they had captured homegrown rural extremists poised for war.
“But the judge said: ‘The court is aware that protected speech and mere words can be sufficient to show a conspiracy. In this case, however, they do not rise to that level.’’
“Judge Roberts granted requests for acquittal on the most serious charges: conspiring to commit sedition, or rebellion, against the U.S. and conspiring to use weapons of mass destruction.
“Other weapons crimes linked to the alleged conspiracies were also dismissed.”
At this point, I believe it is necessary that I review a column I wrote on April 6, 2010, regarding the Hutaree militia raid. As you read the words that follow, please remember that they were written TWO YEARS AGO – almost to the day.
[2010 column starts here] I want to try and expound on William Norman Grigg’s outstanding analysis of the Hutaree militia raid. In doing so, I am going to also expand upon Grigg’s reference to James Madison’s trenchant treatise in Federalist 46.
Referring to the federal indictment against the Hutaree militia, that alleged members were making preparations for potential armed conflict against law enforcement officers as a “seditious conspiracy,” Grigg astutely noted, “If they were acquiring weapons and developing appropriate skills in anticipation of defending themselves against government aggression, their actions – while possibly conspiratorial in nature – don’t amount to a crime. This is particularly true in light of our cultural history, in which sedition – agitation to change the existing political order – is our proudest civic tradition.”
Grigg then rightly observes, “Government is nothing more than the rationalization and exercise of violence. Everything done by government contains at least the implicit threat of lethal coercion. Thus the indictment’s description of Hutaree as ‘an anti-government extremist organization which advocates violence against local, state and Federal law enforcement’ is a product of rhetorical onanism [from Genesis 38:9--a great analogy, Will].”
As a general rule, government is the most violent force on the planet. If one wants to get a true perspective on the historical record regarding who or what routinely produces the most violence and death, one should pick up a copy of R. J. Rummel’s book, “Death By Government.” Since the end of World War II, Communist China and Red Russia lead the pack when it comes to death and brutality; however, the US government has inflicted its share of carnage as well. For example, in Iraq and Afghanistan alone, the government in Washington, D.C., has killed over 800,000 civilians (and this figure is a conservative estimate noting the most credible resources possible).
Plus, does anyone remember the violence that our federal government enacted upon the Branch Davidians outside Waco, Texas? Does anyone remember the mother shot in the head while innocently holding her little baby in her own home by a federal sniper near Ruby Ridge, Idaho (after her small son was shot in the back by federal agents)? In fact, the list of civilians who have been killed by federal law enforcement agents over the years is a very long one. Granted, many of these killings were done in lawful self-defense; but others amounted to nothing less than old-fashioned murder (and never was the federal agent who committed the murder ever brought to justice).
If one wants to indict an “organization which advocates violence,” then surely the central government in Washington, D.C., should be indicted!
If Hutaree members were indeed planning AGGRESSIVE violence against anyone – in the government or without – they deserved to be stopped. If, however, they were simply preparing to DEFEND THEMSELVES against government overreach or abuse – and would only resort to violence in an act of lawful self-defense – they committed no crime and are but the most recent victims of federal abuse of power. This is a question that will doubtless be determined in a court of law.
To charge, however (as the indictment does), that Hutaree members (all 9 of them!) planned “to levy war against the United States, [and] to oppose by force the authority of the Government of the United States . . .” will take some doing to make stick. As Grigg points out, “If Hutaree was preparing for armed DEFENSE against criminal actions by government officials, this charge is as pointless as a broken pencil. If their efforts to ‘prevent, hinder, and delay’ various government initiatives were confined to activism, rather than armed conflict, they are – in that particular – not substantially different from hundreds or thousands of other groups.”
The entire case against Hutaree appears to be based upon the testimony of an FBI undercover agent inside the group. Placing agent provocateurs inside groups such as Hutaree is a classic strategy of federal police agencies. This part of the story was broken by the Wall Street Journal.
See the WSJ report.
Using agent provocateurs is a long-favored tactic of both the Kremlin and the White House. Joel Skousen’s latest WORLD AFFAIRS BRIEF contains an extremely trenchant and insightful analysis of how Russia and the US have used – and continue to use – this tactic.
Skousen writes, “A related tactic [to false flag operations] is the hiring of agent provocateurs to infiltrate a group targeted for destruction and induce radical elements of that group to perform crimes against innocent civilians that will justify armed retaliation or arrest. With the sudden surge in claimed terrorism in Russia and the arrest of the radical Hutaree group in the US, it is helpful to review the role of false flag terror attacks in Russia and the role of agent provocateurs in the US as we analyze what’s really going on.”
Skousen further states, “As we move on to discuss the arrest of the radical members of the Hutaree cult in Michigan, it is important to note that virtually every prosecution of so-called domestic terrorism in the past decade is owed to the infiltration of FBI informants. While none of us in America dispute the need to gain intelligence on real threats to national security, we have to question the propriety of training and pressuring informants (most of which have been forced to accept the informant assignment in lieu of a prison term for other crimes committed) to provoke and induce angry and unstable dissidents to commit acts of terror.
“All too often, FBI ‘informants’ have been pressured by superiors to go far beyond informing. They have provided weapons, explosives, and even acted as the guiding hand to map out the strategy and tactics for performing the deed. These things only come out reluctantly during trial, and even then I suspect that we are never allowed to know the full extent of these provocations.”
To receive a sample of Joel Skousen’s WORLD AFFAIRS BRIEF or to subscribe to this excellent newsletter (I highly recommend it), write to: email@example.com.
In addition, Will Grigg states that another major component of the indictment that is worrisome is the charge that Hutaree is guilty of “seditious conspiracy.” As Grigg writes, “Whatever is eventually learned about Hutaree, as things presently stand the indictment against it could provide a template for ‘seditious conspiracy’ prosecutions involving practically any group that endorses the use of defensive force to protect citizens against government aggression.
“Indeed, the definition of ‘conspiracy’ used in the Hutaree indictment could make a criminal out of anyone who reads Federalist Paper 46 in public, thereby sharing James Madison’s commendably seditious admonition that the people preserve ‘the advantage of being armed’ in the event that insurrection against the central government proves necessary in order to preserve liberty.”
Let’s look a little closer at Federalist 46, written by Founding Father, author of the US Constitution, and America’s fourth President, James Madison. In dispelling the fears of colonists toward a standing federal army, Madison said in Federalist 46, “Let a regular army, fully equal to the resources of the country, be formed; and let it be entirely at the devotion of the federal government; still it would not be going too far to say, that the State governments, with the people on their side, would be able to repel the danger. The highest number to which, according to the best computation, a standing army can be carried in any country, does not exceed one hundredth part of the whole number of souls; or one twenty-fifth part of the number able to bear arms. This proportion would not yield, in the United States, an army of more than twenty-five or thirty thousand men. To these would be opposed a militia amounting to near half a million of citizens with arms in their hands, officered by men chosen from among themselves, fighting for their common liberties, and united and conducted by governments possessing their affections and confidence. It may well be doubted, whether a militia thus circumstanced could ever be conquered by such a proportion of regular troops.”
Madison went on to say, “Besides the advantage of being armed, which the Americans possess over the people of almost every other nation, the existence of subordinate governments, to which the people are attached, and by which the militia officers are appointed, forms a barrier against the enterprises of ambition, more insurmountable than any which a simple government of any form can admit of. Notwithstanding the military establishments in the several kingdoms of Europe, which are carried as far as the public resources will bear, the governments are afraid to trust the people with arms.”
Could Madison be any clearer? He (and the rest of America’s founders) emphatically expected the militia of the “several States” to be universally armed against the potential encroachment on liberty by the central government, meaning: the citizenry must at all times be prepared to use their arms against any aggressive nature of the federal government to trample their freedoms.
This, of course, reinforces the founders’ intent, that the 2nd Amendment protected the right of the people to keep and bear arms for the express purpose of providing the citizenry with the capability to repel (with violence) any assault against their liberties by their own federal government.
So, pray tell, would today’s FBI categorize James Madison’s statements in Federalist 46 as “seditious conspiracy”? If so, perhaps we are closer to tyranny than any of us wants to admit!
Furthermore, it is not lost to millions of Americans that this is the same federal government (through Department of Homeland Security fusion centers) that just recently characterized pro-lifers; people who support the 2nd Amendment; people who oppose the United Nations and illegal immigration; people who voted for Ron Paul or Chuck Baldwin; and Iraq War veterans as “extremists” and potential “dangerous militia members.”
But, once again, the federal government – along with their propagandists in the major news media, including its artificial authority on militias, the ultra-liberal Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) in Montgomery, Alabama – is able to use the Hutaree militia to demonize militias in general, and even more damaging, to try and destroy the concept of constitutional State militias in the minds of the American public.
Did members of the Hutaree intend to carry out aggressive violence against law enforcement personnel? I have no idea. Until this story broke in the national media, I had never heard of this group. I will wait for the facts to come out – if indeed the federal government and national media even allow the facts to come out.
I do know this: I do not trust the federal government to tell the truth about anything! They did not tell the truth about the Branch Davidians at Waco; they did not tell the truth about Randy Weaver; they did not tell the truth about Gordon Kahl; and, if their track record is any indicator, it is doubtful that they are telling the truth about the Hutaree militia. But we shall see.
In the meantime, as William Norman Grigg opines, “There’s reason to believe that the Feds have expanded and escalated this ongoing enterprise to exploit, and exacerbate, growing public hostility toward an increasingly invasive and esurient government.
“Whether it is ever demonstrated that Hutaree intended to ‘levy war’ against the U.S. government, this much is beyond serious dispute: The Homeland Security state is unambiguously preparing for war with the public – in fact, it has been doing so for a long time.” [2010 column ends here]
I invite readers to visit William Norman Grigg’s blog.
Well, now in 2012, the facts have all been laid bare. The Hutaree militia was innocent of the federal government’s conspiracy charges, and the federal government, once again, did not tell the truth. And, furthermore, the words written by yours truly and Will Grigg seem even more relevant today than they did two years ago, do they not?
In closing, let me be very clear about this: I have nothing but appreciation and respect for honest, God-fearing law enforcement personnel. I count law enforcement personnel among my kinfolk, and I feel very privileged to have been made an honorary deputy sheriff by my former county sheriff. I certainly share no anti-law enforcement prejudice. But the current trend to militarize and federalize law enforcement is both unconstitutional and alarming. Even more alarming is the manner in which the federal government and its toadies at the SPLC are attempting to criminalize the expressions of freedom and constitutional government – the same words, thoughts, and ideas expressed by America’s Founding Fathers. To quote myself, “So, pray tell, would today’s FBI categorize James Madison’s statements in Federalist 46 as ‘seditious conspiracy’? If so, perhaps we are closer to tyranny than any of us wants to admit!”
In the meantime, congratulations to federal District Judge Victoria Roberts for representing the court in a manner consistent with the founders’ intentions: by using the gavel as a hammer to protect liberty rather than as a rubber stamp to dismantle it – as so many federal judges are inclined to do these days.
April 7, 2012
Copyright © 2012 Chuck Baldwin
News for Life, Liberty, & Property
I found these two videos on youtube and thought they went well together. Enjoy. English Longbow History “A brief discussion of the English Longbow. This video was shot on request from my brother for use in the English Lit. class that he teaches when they were studying Robin Hood. It was quick, off the top of my head, and on a tight time schedule, but I had fun doing it!” Making Replica Medieval Arrows A step-by-step look at how I make 1/2″...Read more
Time to add another tool to your tool box Liberty lovers. Survival cooking or how to prepare food in the wild is an essential skill for the wilderness or urban survivor. A good example of a simple cooking method is “The Swedish Fire Torch”. Read on and watch the videos to learn about this awesome all in one stove. “Schwedenfackel (German). Roughly translated, it means “Swedish fire torch”, also known by other names, to include Swedish (log) candle, and Swedish lo...Read more
Something that could come in handy in a survival situation is a way to kill critters for food. Hint a bow. Even if you are not planning for survival in the New Amerika… (which you might ought to think about) This would be a GREAT family or home school project. This bow has many possibilities and will provide hours of entertainment while practicing a valuable survival skill. So add another tool to your tool box and check out this very interesting and unique video… How to make a Su...Read more
This seems to be a good video to give you some basic information on self defense shooting from retention. Check this video out and watch, listen, and learn how to defend your life, Liberty, and Property! Self Defense: Shooting From Retention Fun Gun Review Presents:”Shooting From Retention: Trained To Shoot” Defensive Firearms Training. Robbie Wheaton of Wheaton Arms is using his experience from the Marine Corps and as a Master Class Competitor in IPDA, USPSA, and 3 Gun Matches, ...Read more
The Army Ranger and Iraq war veteran David Kirk West’s anti-war film inspired by his experiences in Iraq. One Man’s Terrorist is a speculative anti-war drama set against the back-drop of an America that has fallen into chaos. Elections have been postponed, martial law has been instituted, and a massive federal land grab on the California/Oregon border has inspired a secessionist movement in the “State of Jefferson” region. The film tells the tale of both the soldiers s...Read more
Stopping the Next Hitler by Bill Walker The US is about to launch yet another undeclared war on yet another eastern front, this time against Iran. Supposedly our permanent state of war is necessary to “stop the next Hitler”…. in other words, the way to prevent a Nazi regime from arising is to launch surprise attacks on small countries, round up Semitic scapegoats and put them in secret camps, spy on our own people with 17 Gestapo-style intelligence agencies, build a series ...Read more
By: Michael Pearl WARNING This article contains information targeting married couples and mature teenagers. You should read it first and then decide if you want your children to read it. Be prepared to answer their questions. Dear Debi, My husband and I have been married for 14 years. During those years my husband has back-sliden several times. During those times he was involved in pornography. For the last nine months he has been praying and reading the Word, fellowshipping, leading devotion...Read more
Patrick Henry – “I know of no way of judging of the future but by the past.” Does The Past Sound Familiar?
Patrick Henry – Give Me Liberty Or Give Me Death Patrick Henry, March 23, 1775. (in Saint John’s Church in Richmond) No man thinks more highly than I do of the patriotism, as well as abilities, of the very worthy gentlemen who have just addressed the House. But different men often see the same subject in different lights; and, therefore, I hope it will not be thought disrespectful to those gentlemen if, entertaining as I do opinions of a character very opposite to theirs, I s...Read more
Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn Said They Could Have Stopped Stalin Dead But “We did not love freedom enough”! How Can You Stop Tyranny?
“During an arrest, you think since you are not guilty, how can they arrest you? Why should you run away? And how can you resist right then? After all, you’ll only make your situation worse; you will make it more difficult for them to sort out the mistake. And how we burned in the camps later, thinking: What would things have been like if every Security operative, when he went out at night to make an arrest, had been uncertain whether he would return alive and had to say goodbye to hi...Read more
The Capitalist Conspiracy An Inside View Of International Banking G. Edward Griffin – The Capitalist Conspiracy: An Inside view of International Banking Written and narrated by G. Edward Griffin (1960′s) An old film, made sometime in the 60′s. This is an adaptation of a documentary filmstrip tracing the history of a small group of people who control the money systems of the world. It shows how this group is protected by governments and how its wealth is derived by creating m...Read more
Time To Wake Up: Will Troops Be Ordered To Kill Americans Who Do Not Turn In Guns? Documents Say To!!
Does this sound like a Headline from Nazi Germany or Stalins Russia? It’s not. It’s here in the United States of America.. Why? Because WE let it happen… Watch and learn from others Nations that have let themselves be disarmed : Please spread the Word. UN Gun Grab Follows State Department Plan http://libertychatter.com/un-gun-grab-follows-state-department-plan/ Army Manual Outlines Plan To Kill Rioters, Demonstrators In America http://libertychatter.com/army-manual-outline...Read more
Don’t Try That In Montana! (chuckbaldwinlive.com) By now, everybody in the country knows about the horrific shootings at a packed theater in the metro Denver area last week. Twelve people were killed and scores were wounded. Predictably, gun-control zealots nationwide are shouting for stricter gun control laws. Not only that, some are even calling for the TSA to set up airport-style screening devices in movie theaters. So, if the TSA is going to set up screening devices for movie theaters, ...Read more
Real Pastor Stands His Ground After Being Viciously Beaten & Tazed By Border Patrol Thugs A Few Years Ago Now He Says “NO” To Police State Checkpoints & Gets Waved Through!
“Thank you God for men who are willing to standagainst corruption! Men like this are willing to die for our liberty and we should be so grateful! The following video of Pastor Steven Anderson standing his ground at an unlawful checkpoint.” – LibertyChatter.com Forums “Westbound I-8 in Southern California (an East-West highway that NEVER intersects the international border).” http://www.sanderson1611.blogspot.com http://www.faithfulwordbaptist.org http:...Read more
“No Guns for Negroes ” exposes the racist history of American gun control laws. Every person who supports gun control laws must be shown this film or gun ownership will cease to exist in America. Aaron S. Zelman, who recently passed away, was the founder of Jews for the Preservation of Firearms Ownership (JFPO) has been a notable advocate not only for 2nd Amendment rights, but for breaking down the racial stigma(s) surrounding gun ownership. One of his other films, No Guns for Jews, bears...Read more
While Ice T cannot be commended for his wild lifestyle he does a good job of telling off an anti-Liberty Gun Grabber… Even Ice T a wild Un-holywood type has enough sense not to give up his guns! “Tracy Marrow, better known by his stage name Ice-T, is an American musician and actor. He was born in Newark, New Jersey, and moved to the Crenshaw district of Los Angeles when he was in the 7th grade.” – Wikipedia Twitter Comment about the interview: “My comment on g...Read more
“Complete disarmament” of the American people Paul Joseph Watson (Infowars.com) The UN Arms Trade Treaty that has been identified by observers as a flagrant threat to the second amendment and which Barack Obama is determined to sign has its roots in a 1961 State Department memorandum which explains how the United Nations will oversee “complete disarmament” of the American people under the ruse of preventing war. The UN Arms Treaty has caused so much controversy because it outlines a ...Read more
“Statesmen, my dear Sir, may plan and speculate for Liberty, but it is Religion and Morality alone, which can establish the Principles upon which Freedom can securely stand. The only foundation of a free Constitution is pure Virtue, and if this cannot be inspired into our People in a greater Measure than they have it now, They may change their Rulers and the forms of Government, but they will not obtain a lasting Liberty. They will only exchange Tyrants and Tyrannies.” ~ John Adams Letter...Read more
Are We Living Under the Communist Manifesto? “A nation can survive its fools, and even the ambitious. But it cannot survive treason from within. An enemy at the gates is less formidable, for he is known, and he carries his banners openly. But the traitor moves among those within the gates freely, his sly whispers rustling through all the alleys, heard in the very hall of government itself. For the traitor appears no traitor. He speaks in the accents familiar to his victims, and...Read more
How Communists Conspirators Took Over The Civil Rights Movement And The Template Still Works Today With Trayvon Martin Hysteria
“Anarchy USA: In the Name of Civil Rights USA: A documentary demonstrating how Communists were behind the civil rights movement. The template used in America is viewed in light of prior unrest in Algeria, Cuba, and China.” In this documentary “Anarchy USA” G. Edward Griffin does an amazing job of exposing the blueprint, the play book that the Communists use to infiltrate countries and movements alike. He documents how the doctrine of “Divide and Conquer then Sla...Read more
A Day in the (Prison) Life February 8th, 2012 by CSE (for Dr. Hovind) A Day in the (Prison) Life of Kent Hovind Written on January 19, 2012 Five years ago today I was sentenced to ten years in federal prison — three of them for praying for a man on the radio and five of them for taking our own ministry money out of our own ministry bank account to pay the ministry bills! Whoda’ thought it could happen in America? It actually might be funny if it were not happening to me! The case is still...Read more
Why Was 63-year-old Highly Decorated World War II Vet Gordon Kahl Beat With Rifles, Bones Broke, Shot In The Back Of Head, Body Dismembered, Then Burned? (A Story of Death & Taxes)
The Murder Of Gordon Kahl By Mary Sparrowdancer ©. 2007 All Rights Reserved 2-14-7 Gordon Kahl was viciously murdered in 1983 by a gang of brutal criminals who have never been brought to justice. As though his mere execution was not enough to satisfy his tormentors, they beat the 63-year-old Kahl with the butts of their rifles, breaking multiple bones and teeth and further mutilated him through dismemberment. One foot would later be found under a refrigerator in the ruins of the house tha...Read more
Members Of A Michigan Militia (Hutaree) Have Been Cleared Of Plotting To Overthrow the U.S. Government
Hutaree Militiamen Cleared In Court by Chuck Baldwin Much to the chagrin of the Southern Poverty Law Center, a federal judge has cleared the members of a Michigan militia who were accused by federal law enforcement agents of conspiracy to commit sedition. Since you didn’t hear much about this ruling from the national press corps, here is one online version of the report: “Seven members of a Michigan militia have been cleared of plotting to overthrow the U.S. government as a judge dismiss...Read more
A Look at How Democrats and Republicans Differ by Chuck Baldwin It is an absolute fact that no matter which of the two major parties in Washington, D.C., is in power, the freedoms and liberties of the American people continue to be eroded. However, this does NOT mean that there are not basic differences between the two parties. The two parties differ greatly on HOW government will take our liberties. Where they are similar is in the fact that neither of them has any interest in preserving lib...Read more
The Dangers of Evolution In The Dangers of Evolution, Dr. Hovind reveals the terrible effects that evolutionary beliefs have had on societies throughout history. Giving examples of evolution-based philosophies being used to rationalize the brutal acts of rulers, he exposes evolutionary propaganda in its effort toward the “New World Order.”Read more
Homeland Security Report Lists ‘Liberty Lovers’, Christians, Conservatives, & Libertarians As Terrorists
Americans who are “suspicious of centralized federal authority, reverent of individual liberty” deemed domestic threat Paul Joseph Watson (Infowars.com) A new study funded by the Department of Homeland Security characterizes Americans who are “suspicious of centralized federal authority,” and “reverent of individual liberty” as “extreme right-wing” terrorists. Entitled Hot Spots of Terrorism and Other Crimes in the United States, 1970-2008 (PDF), the study was produced by ...Read more
The Mine Resistant Ambush Protected (commonly known as the MRAP) was developed and rushed into production to protect soldiers and Marines in Iraq and Afghanistan from large Improvised Explosive Devices (IEDs). IEDs were made primarily of artillery shells, copper shaped charge penetrators, and large bombs made of fertilizer & fuel oil. The IEDs were getting so large and so sophisticated that the heavily up-armored HMMVW were no longer effective protection. Now a up-armored HMMVW is ...Read more
“Warning shots will not be fired” (Prison Planet.com) A newly leaked US Army Military Police training manual for “Civil Disturbance Operations” outlines how military assets are to be used domestically to quell riots, confiscate firearms and even kill Americans on U.S. soil during mass civil unrest. The document (PDF), which is dated 2006 and was used for a self-learning course at the U.S. Army Military Police School at Fort McClellan, makes it clear that the operations described in t...Read more
Video of Scumbag Lincoln Officer Edward Krawetz: A Rhode Island cop who was convicted of a felony after he was caught on video kicking a handcuffed woman to the head is still employed as a police officer. Lincoln police officer Edward Krawetz kicked the woman in the head in 2009 claiming self-defense because apparently he was in fear for his life. He didn’t go to trial until March of this year. He was convicted and sentenced to ten years in prison but because he is a cop, the judge suspen...Read more