Seven Shots, One Child, and Unanswered Questions

Aaron Guiel near police car behind yellow caution tape — Photo: Eric Crudup / Shutterstock

DHS says ICE agents shot a wanted criminal illegal alien during a targeted arrest as the suspect’s car moved with a 5-year-old inside, and they will not pause enforcement while the FBI investigates.

Story Highlights

DHS says this was a targeted arrest of a Dominican national with a prior grand larceny conviction and multiple arrests.
NYPD says the driver started to pull the car forward before at least seven shots were fired; the child was unharmed.
DHS says agents rendered aid immediately; the man is hospitalized and the FBI and Homeland Security Investigations are probing.
DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin says ICE will not pause enforcement in New York City after the incident.

What DHS and Police Say Happened in Marble Hill

Department of Homeland Security officials say Immigration and Customs Enforcement was running a targeted operation to arrest a criminal illegal alien from the Dominican Republic with a prior conviction for grand larceny and multiple arrests for assault, robbery, drug possession, and weapons possession. New York City Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch said the 28-year-old, identified as Oscar Belgal, was pulling into a parking space when a federal officer approached with a gun drawn, and Belgal then started to move the car forward before at least seven shots were fired. A five-year-old was in the back seat and was not hurt.

DHS said ICE officers rendered aid right away, the man survived, and the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and Homeland Security Investigations are on scene leading an active investigation. Officials have not released body-camera or dash camera video to the public. The lack of video leaves open questions about speed, angle, and any contact. Those details matter for judging whether officers faced an immediate threat, which is the standard in vehicle-related shootings under court rulings and agency policies.

Why ICE Targeted the Suspect and What Comes Next

Officials say Belgal’s criminal history justified the arrest target, and that ICE agents attempted to remove a repeat offender from the streets. Naming the suspect, describing his record, and noting the child’s presence give a clearer picture of risk factors agents weighed in real time. Still, investigators must confirm whether the officer who fired knew those details at the moment and whether the car’s movement posed an immediate danger to agents or the child. The Fourth Amendment requires force to be objectively reasonable.

In police encounters with moving vehicles, courts look hard at whether an officer or bystander was in the direct path and in imminent danger. Training guides also warn officers not to shoot at vehicles unless a separate deadly threat exists beyond the car itself. A full reconstruction can show speed, trajectory, and shot angles. That is why ballistic paths, shell casings, and any street camera footage will be key to the FBI’s findings. Until that record is public, precision on the moment of decision is limited.

Politics, Protests, and the Trump Administration’s Stance

Protesters gathered outside New York Presbyterian Allen Hospital, chanting for ICE to leave the Bronx and demanding answers. Mayor Zohran Mamdani claimed there was no justification for firing so many rounds into a car with a child, and he pushed President Trump to halt ICE operations in the city. Commissioner Tisch confirmed at least seven shots struck and wounded the driver below his left ear, while stressing that the child was unharmed and placed with a relative after the shooting.

DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin blasted sanctuary city policies following an ICE shooting in the Bronx, saying they undermine public safety and create an environment where crime can thrive. “When you have sanctuary cities and sanctuary politicians, you endanger the safety of the… pic.twitter.com/rda98GbjJK

— Breaking911 (@Breaking911) October 9, 2026

Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin said ICE will not pause enforcement in New York, signaling that the administration will continue to prioritize arrests of criminal illegal aliens while the investigation runs its course. For readers who want safe streets, this stance affirms a basic duty: government must remove violent offenders and protect children. The facts now on record support that officers acted, aided the suspect, and turned the case over to federal investigators. The next step is evidence release to verify the split-second threat call.